The Player, The Moment

Darren Sproles was 5-foot-6, maybe 180 pounds on a generous day, and heard “too small” his entire career. In 2003, he made that argument look ridiculous: he led the entire nation with 1,986 rushing yards, added enough receiving and return yardage to total 2,735 all-purpose yards, still a Big 12 single-season record more than two decades later, and finished fifth in Heisman voting. He capped it by leading Kansas State to its first conference title since 1934, rushing for 235 yards in the Big 12 Championship Game in an upset of the No. 1 team in the country, Oklahoma. The signature play of his career came in that exact game: taking a handoff, spinning clean out of All-American cornerback Derrick Strait’s grip, and turning it into a 55-yard gain. Oklahoma’s own head coach, Bob Stoops, described it afterward like he’d watched something that shouldn’t have been possible.

By the time he left Kansas State, Sproles held 23 school and conference records, including 4,979 career rushing yards (still 11th all-time in NCAA history) and 6,812 career all-purpose yards, a Big 12 record that also ranks 19th all-time nationally, ahead of almost every Power Five player who’s ever done it. He went on to a 15-year NFL career, a Super Bowl ring, and retired 5th all-time in NFL all-purpose yardage.

There was no NIL in 2003. A player who spent his entire career being told he was too small to matter, then went out and became one of the most productive all-purpose weapons the sport has ever seen, made zero dollars off any of it.

So what would that season be worth today? I built an estimate.

Read more

The Player, The Moment

Terrell Suggs was a high school running back before Arizona State converted him to defensive end. In 2002, his junior season, he set an NCAA single-season sack record that still stands more than two decades later: 24 sacks, shattering the previous record of 17.5. He also led the nation with 31.5 tackles for loss, was a unanimous first-team All-American, won the Nagurski, Hendricks, and Lombardi awards, and helped drag Arizona State to an 8-6 record, its first winning season since 1997. He finished his college career with 44 sacks and 65.5 tackles for loss, both still ASU records. The sack mark isn’t just his record anymore; it’s the record, full stop, and nobody has come within striking distance of it since.

There was no NIL in 2002. The single greatest pass-rushing season college football has ever seen; one that’s now outlasted every other record on this list in terms of how long it’s stood unbroken, produced zero off-field income for the player who authored it.

So what would that season be worth today? I built an estimate, and this one comes with a real surprise buried in the numbers.

Read more

The Player, The Moment

On October 22, 2016, Patrick Mahomes threw for 734 yards and ran for 85 more against Oklahoma; 819 total yards, an FBS record that still stands. He did it on 88 pass attempts, one shy of the all-time record, completing 52 of them for five touchdowns and adding two more scores on the ground. Texas Tech and Oklahoma combined for 1,708 yards of total offense that night, still the most in any Big 12 game ever played. Mahomes lost. Oklahoma won 66-59.

That game is the headline, but it wasn’t a one-off. Mahomes led the entire nation in total offense as a junior in 2016, throwing for 5,052 yards. He closed his college career with 586 yards and six touchdowns in his final game. He did it all as a three-sport athlete out of high school who was also drafted by the Detroit Tigers as a baseball pitcher. And he did it all on a Texas Tech team that finished the 2016 season 5-7; no bowl game, no signature win, nothing but the numbers themselves to point to.

There was no NIL in 2016. The single most jaw-dropping statistical season in recent college football history produced zero off-field income for the player who authored it, largely because the team around him didn’t win enough games to make anyone outside Lubbock pay attention while it was happening.

So what would that season be worth today, when a highlight reel travels a lot further than a win-loss record does? I built an estimate.

Read more

The Player, The Moment

Barry Sanders was so lightly recruited out of Wichita North High School that his only scholarship offers came from Emporia State, Tulsa, and Oklahoma State. He didn’t even become OSU’s starting running back until his junior year, spending his first two seasons backing up Thurman Thomas and touching the ball only 105 times combined. Then Thomas left for the NFL, the job opened up, and Sanders produced what is still, nearly forty years later, regarded as the single greatest season any running back has ever had at any level of football.

The numbers don’t really look real: 2,628 rushing yards, 37 rushing touchdowns, 39 total touchdowns, 3,250 all-purpose yards; every one of those still an NCAA record today. He averaged 238.9 yards per game. He had four separate 300-yard rushing games in the same season. He scored at least two touchdowns in eleven consecutive games. He won the Heisman in a landslide, accepting it via satellite from Tokyo because Oklahoma State was already overseas for a game against Texas Tech; a game in which he then went out and put up 332 yards and four more touchdowns anyway, hours after the trophy was in hand.

There was no NIL in 1988. A season that’s still statistically untouched by anyone since produced zero off-field dollars for the player who did it.

So what would that season actually be worth today? I built an estimate, and it comes with a real wrinkle.

The Methodology

Same approach as always: comparing against real, reported modern NIL valuations for the closest available comps. But Sanders’ case surfaces something the RG3 estimate didn’t have to deal with directly. Position matters enormously in today’s NIL market, and running backs get hit the hardest by it.

The real numbers are stark. Even the best running backs in the country right now are valued far below top quarterbacks:

• Arch Manning currently sits at the top of the sport at a reported $5.3–6.8 million

• The single highest-valued running back in the country, Notre Dame’s Jeremiyah Love, is valued around $1.5–1.6 million, roughly a quarter of Manning’s number

• Typical elite running backs generally land in the $800,000–$2 million range, even with major production, largely because touches, ball-control offenses, and injury risk make the position a harder sell to collectives and brands than a quarterback or a true alpha receiver

That gap exists for real market reasons, not just old-school bias, but it also means even a legendary running back season starts from a lower ceiling than an equivalent quarterback season would.

Where Barry Sanders Lands

Here’s the case for busting through that ceiling anyway: Sanders’ 1988 season isn’t just “a great running back year,” it’s a genuinely unrepeated statistical anomaly; records that have stood for nearly four decades despite a much faster, much higher-scoring modern game. That level of mythology has real commercial value on its own; a player who is still, to this day, the answer to “greatest single season ever” is a marketing story most current players simply don’t have access to, regardless of position.

Balancing the real positional discount against a season that’s genuinely without peer, Sanders lands well above the current running back ceiling, but still short of what a top-tier modern quarterback commands, because that positional gap is real and wouldn’t fully disappear just because the season was historic.

There’s also a market-size factor worth being honest about, same as with Baylor in the RG3 piece. Stillwater is a town of about 48,000 people, an hour’s drive from both Oklahoma City and Tulsa; by any modern measure, one of the smallest true media markets housing a major college football program in the country. A player at Texas or Ohio State gets a built-in marketing multiplier just from campus size and local media saturation that a player at Oklahoma State simply doesn’t have access to, regardless of how good he is.

That’s actually part of what makes this pick fun, and it’s not a coincidence that Oklahoma State is also this newsletter’s Dark Horse pick for 2026: this is a program that has produced legitimate, sport-altering talent out of a market a fraction of the size of its rivals, more than once. If Eric Morris’s roster overhaul pays off this season, it’ll be the same basic story playing out again, a small-market program producing outsized results. Sanders’ number below already accounts for that market discount; it’s also a reminder of exactly how much he had to overcome to get that number as high as it is.

*Estimated 1988 NIL value: $3.4 million

That’s more than double the highest-valued running back in the country today, and still meaningfully behind the Arch Mannings of the world. Was I too conservative; does a season this untouchable deserve to blow through the position discount entirely? Or does the modern math hold up even for a legend like this? Tell me in the comments.

Next week in Before the Bag: a Big 12 legend who once posted 819 total yards in a single game; a record that still stands; on a team that finished the year with a losing record. He'd go on to become a three-time Super Bowl champion. His college numbers were just as ridiculous as you'd expect.

*These are opinion-based estimates for entertainment, not real financial claims.

For paid subscribers only — please don’t forward or repost.

The Player, The Moment

In 1990, Ty Detmer threw for 5,188 yards and 41 touchdowns, adding 5,022 yards of total offense, numbers that would be enormous by today’s spread-offense standards and were nearly unthinkable in 1990, an era of run-heavy, ground-and-pound college football. He broke 42 NCAA records in that single season. The signature moment came in just the second game of the year: a 28-21 upset of defending national champion Miami in Provo, with Detmer throwing for 406 yards and three touchdowns against a Hurricanes defense that was supposed to be untouchable. He won the Heisman in a landslide, finishing with nearly 300 more points than the runner-up. By the time his career ended, he’d broken 59 NCAA records and left with 15,031 career passing yards, an NCAA record at the time, still fifth all-time today, more than three decades later.

Here’s the part that makes his story different from everyone else in this series: BYU wasn’t just worried about NIL not existing yet, they were worried nobody outside Utah would even notice the season while it was happening. Detmer played his conference schedule outside the sport’s power structure at the time, and BYU’s sports information staff ran what amounted to a full public-relations campaign; mailers, media outreach, a “neck-tie” branding push, specifically to make sure Heisman voters knew who he was. The stats alone, it turns out, weren’t considered enough to guarantee attention. They had to manufacture the spotlight themselves.

There was no NIL in 1990, obviously. But the deeper irony is that BYU was already fighting the exact battle every school fights in the NIL era: the battle for attention; they just had to do it with press releases instead of a collective.

So what would that season be worth today, in a media environment that would have made Detmer’s numbers go viral on their own? I built an estimate.

Read more

The Player, The Moment

In 2011, Robert Griffin III did something that felt almost impossible at the time: he made Baylor football must-watch television. Baylor hadn’t posted a winning Big 12 record in over a decade. RG3 threw for 4,293 yards, ran for another 699, accounted for 47 total touchdowns, completed better than 72% of his passes, and dragged the Bears to a 10-win season and an Alamo Bowl win; the program’s best finish in a generation. He won the Heisman Trophy by one of the closest margins in the award’s history, edging Andrew Luck. Off the field, he was a legitimate track star with real Olympic-trial hurdles credentials, exactly the kind of crossover, highlight-reel athlete that would break the internet today.

There was no NIL in 2011. Griffin left Baylor with a Heisman, a degree, and functionally zero dollars earned off of one of the most electric individual seasons college football had ever seen.

So what would he actually be worth in today’s market? I built an estimate, and the number might surprise you.

The Methodology

Since we obviously can’t know what RG3 would have actually signed for, this is built by comparing him against real, reported NIL valuations for similarly-profiled modern players; Heisman-caliber dual threats who took a non-blue-blood program on an improbable run. A few benchmarks worth knowing:

• Shedeur Sanders peaked around a reported $6.2 million NIL valuation at Colorado, largely driven by his father’s fame, a viral turnaround story, and massive social reach — despite not winning a Heisman

• Arch Manning has carried valuations in the $3.8–6.8 million range without even being a full-time starter for most of that stretch, almost entirely on name recognition and market size (Texas)

• Caleb Williams, as a reigning Heisman winner having a rockier follow-up season, still held a reported valuation around $2.8 million

The formula roughly weighs: market/program size, team success and media exposure, position premium (quarterback always sits at the top), and the “viral moment” factor; how shareable and story-driven the season itself is.

Where RG3 Lands

RG3’s case is unusually strong on the “story” and “highlight” factors specifically; a dual-threat Heisman winner with track-star athleticism and a background-to-breakout narrative is about as made-for-modern-media as a college football story gets, arguably more shareable than most of the names above. Where he loses ground is program size: Baylor in 2011, even after the breakout season, was not pulling in Texas- or USC-level attention. Worth noting the market too: Waco sits at roughly 140,000 people, wedged almost exactly halfway between Dallas and Austin rather than being its own major media market. Before 2011, Baylor simply wasn't a program most of the country was paying attention to; the Heisman run is what put Waco on the map nationally, not the other way around. RG3 had to generate his own spotlight, with no built-in market size doing any of the work for him.

His combination of a breakout, viral‑level season and a smaller market, puts him in the territory comparable to peak Shedeur Sanders; a superstar turning a non‑national program into a headline act.

*Estimated 2011 NIL value: $4.6 million

That's real money for a single college season, but it's also a number built almost entirely on how good the story was, not program size or existing hype. Is a transcendent individual season enough to overcome playing at a smaller program, or does market size cap you no matter how good you are? And with Baylor now a very different, better-funded program than it was in 2011; would a repeat performance be worth even more today?

Next week in Before the Bag: the single greatest season any college running back has ever had; records that still stand nearly forty years later; belonging to a player who was so overlooked in high school he only had three scholarship offers.

New Before the Bag drops every week. Subscribe free so you don’t miss the next one.

Subscribe now

*These are opinion-based estimates for entertainment, not real financial claims.*

For paid subscribers only — please don’t forward or repost.